🪰439,131 violations tracked across 67 Florida counties

Best Italian Restaurants in Saint Augustine, Florida

Saint Augustine has no shortage of italian options, but which ones pass the health inspection test with flying colors? Here are the cleanest, ranked by score.

Showing top 20 of 48 italian restaurants in Saint Augustine

#1

BELLATRINO PIZZERIA

59 WEST AVENUE, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

100/100
#2

PAPA JOHN'S

4255 US 1 S STE 15-16, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

100/100
#3

DELLA TORRE’S ITALIAN DELI

180 REGISTRY BLVD STE 102, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

100/100
#4

ONLY PIZZA LLC

950 FL 206, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

100/100
#5

NYC MEATBALLS & PIZZERIA STA

2730 101-103, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

100/100
#6

THUNDER J'S PIZZERIA

3915 A1A S STE 105, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

100/100
#7

BRONX HOUSE PIZZA

389 PASEO REYES DR STE 205, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

99.5/100
#8

PIZZA HUT 4283

156 SR 312, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98.8/100
#9

NONNA'S TRATTORIA

2 AVILES ST, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98.8/100
#10

MARCOS PIZZA

74 CAPULET DRIVE SUITE 207, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98.5/100
#11

ANTONIOS NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA ON THE BEACH

378 A1A BEACH BLVD, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98.5/100
#12

PIZZA HUT #4282

525 SR 16 #116, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98.5/100
#13

MARCO'S PIZZA #8614

230 PLAZA BLVD STE 6, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98.5/100
#14

DERITA ITALIAN DELI

155 HAMPTON PT DR STE 4, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98/100
#15

SALS CUCINA TASTE OF ITALY

145 BRONZ GLOW WAY, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

98/100
#16

DOMINO'S #5105

3570 US 1 S, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

97.5/100
#17

DOMINO'S PIZZA 8609

1967 OLD MOULTRIE RD, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

97/100
#18

MELLOW MUSHROOM RESTAURANT

410 ANASTASIA BLVD, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

97/100
#19

PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA

10440 US 1 N #122, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

97/100
#20

PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA

105 MURABELLA PKWY #4, SAINT AUGUSTINE

A

96.5/100
All restaurants in Saint Augustine → All Italian in Florida →