Best Italian Restaurants in Saint Augustine, Florida
Looking for the cleanest italian restaurants in Saint Augustine? We ranked all 15 Saint Augustine italian spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 15 are below. DELLA TORRE’S ITALIAN DELI leads the list with a score of 100 — an A grade based on consistently clean inspections. 3 of the top 15 carry an A grade; the rest sit in B-grade territory or lower. Average health score across this list: 90.2.
Showing top 15 of 15 italian restaurants in Saint Augustine
DELLA TORRE’S ITALIAN DELI
180 REGISTRY BLVD STE 102, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
RUFINO'S PIZZA
2700 SR 16 #207, SAINT AUGUSTINE
97/100
MARCO'S PIZZA #8614
230 PLAZA BLVD STE 6, SAINT AUGUSTINE
96/100
CHIANTI ROOM
60 CHARLOTTE ST, SAINT AUGUSTINE
93/100
DOMINO'S #4902
2085 SR 3 #106, SAINT AUGUSTINE
92/100
VINNY'S NY STYLE PIZZA
105 YACHT CLUB DR, SAINT AUGUSTINE
91/100
NYC MEATBALLS & PIZZERIA STA
2730 101-103, SAINT AUGUSTINE
90/100
STONERS PIZZA
196 CAPULET DR STE 5, SAINT AUGUSTINE
90/100
PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA
105 MURABELLA PKWY #4, SAINT AUGUSTINE
89.8/100
CARRABBA'S ITALIAN GRILL #6036
155 SR 312 W, SAINT AUGUSTINE
89/100
MELLOW MUSHROOM
5330 FL-16, SAINT AUGUSTINE
87.5/100
ROSATI'S PIZZA
520 W TWINCOURT TRL STE 6, SAINT AUGUSTINE
87/100
PIZZA TIME
124 ST GEORGE ST, SAINT AUGUSTINE
85.6/100
ST AUGIE'S PIZZA
113 1/2 KING ST, SAINT AUGUSTINE
85/100
ROMANO'S PIZZERIA AND RESTAURANT
4010 US 1 SOUTH STE 113-115, SAINT AUGUSTINE
80.5/100
