Best Pizza Restaurants in Key West, Florida
Looking for the cleanest pizza restaurants in Key West? We ranked all 19 Key West pizza spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 19 are below. WHITE STREET PIZZA leads the list with a score of 100 — an A grade based on consistently clean inspections. 3 of the top 19 carry an A grade; the rest sit in B-grade territory or lower. Average health score across this list: 83.2.
Showing top 19 of 19 pizza restaurants in Key West
WHITE STREET PIZZA
1110 WHITE ST, KEY WEST
100/100
CLEMENTES WOOD FIRED TROLLEY PIZZERIA
629 DUVAL ST, KEY WEST
100/100
PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA
2504 N ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
96.6/100
GLADIATOR GELATO
407 FRONT ST, KEY WEST
94.2/100
MAESTRO DELLA PIZZA/STARBUCKS
3495 S ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
94/100
ONLYWOOD PIZZERIA TRATTORIA
613 1/2 DUVAL STREET, KEY WEST
93/100
LA TRATTORIA OCEANSIDE
3593 S ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
91.8/100
LA TRATTORIA/ VIRGILIOS
524 DUVAL STREET, KEY WEST
91.4/100
PIZZA HUT
2300 N ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
90.5/100
ANTONIA'S
615 DUVAL STREET, KEY WEST
87.8/100
BIG JOHN'S PIZZA
1103 KEY PLAZA, KEY WEST
83/100
CLEMENTE'S WOOD-FIRED PIZZERIA
516 FLEMING ST BOTTOM FLOOR, KEY WEST
82.3/100
ANGELINA'S PIZZA
208 DUVAL ST, KEY WEST
81.7/100
DOMINO'S PIZZA
2704 N ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
78.1/100
PIZZA JOES
724 DUVAL ST, KEY WEST
71.7/100
MANGIA MANGIA
900 SOUTHARD ST, KEY WEST
70.9/100
ROOSTICA PIZZERIA
5620 MACDONALD AVE, KEY WEST
64.8/100
ABBONDANZA RESTAURANT
1208 SIMONTON ST, KEY WEST
61/100
NEW YORK PASTA GARDEN
1075 DUVAL C1, KEY WEST
47.2/100
