Best Italian Restaurants in Gainesville, Florida
Looking for the cleanest italian restaurants in Gainesville? We ranked all 44 Gainesville italian spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 20 are below. STREGA NONA'S OVEN leads the list with a score of 100 — an A grade based on consistently clean inspections. 15 of the top 20 carry an A grade; the rest sit in B-grade territory or lower. Average health score across this list: 96.7.
Showing top 20 of 44 italian restaurants in Gainesville
STREGA NONA'S OVEN
4150 NW 16 BLVD, GAINESVILLE
100/100
DALMOROS FRESH PASTA TO GO
16 NW 18 ST STE 120, GAINESVILLE
99.3/100
DOMINO'S PIZZA #3172
5750 SW 75 ST STE 40, GAINESVILLE
99/100
DOMINO'S #8643
3320 SW 35 BLVD, GAINESVILLE
99/100
PIZZAFÉ
4005 NW 13 ST, GAINESVILLE
98.8/100
PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA #498
3605 SW ARCHER RD, GAINESVILLE
98/100
SQUAREHOUSE PIZZA
405 SW 4 AVE, GAINESVILLE
98/100
ITALIAN GATOR PIZZA
1728 W UNIVERSITY AVE #A, GAINESVILLE
97.8/100
PIESANOS STONE FIRED PIZZA
5757 SW 75 ST UNIT 101, GAINESVILLE
97.5/100
COURT OF HERO'S & GUMBY'S PIZZA
2028 SW 34TH ST, GAINESVILLE
97/100
DOMINO'S PIZZA #3214
133 SW 34 ST, GAINESVILLE
96.9/100
HUNGRY HOWIES
1310 NW 23 AVE STE-B, GAINESVILLE
96.5/100
PEPPINO'S PIZZA
3731 W UNIVERSITY AVE, GAINESVILLE
96/100
LITTLE CAESARS PIZZA
5162 SW 34 ST, GAINESVILLE
95.5/100
DOMINO'S PIZZA 8643
3581 SW ARCHER RD STE 10, GAINESVILLE
95.4/100
DOMINO'S PIZZA 3212
25 NW 16 AVE STE 500, GAINESVILLE
94.5/100
PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA #5049
1710 SW 13 ST, GAINESVILLE
94/100
PIZZA HUT / WING STREET
7331 NW 4 BLVD, GAINESVILLE
93.9/100
LEONARDO'S PIZZA OF MILLHOPPER
4131 NW 16 BLVD, GAINESVILLE
93.8/100
FIVE STAR PIZZA
1315 S MAIN ST STE 10, GAINESVILLE
93.4/100
