Best Seafood Restaurants in Key West, Florida
Looking for the cleanest seafood restaurants in Key West? We ranked all 30 Key West seafood spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 20 are below. THE MERMAID & THE ALLIGATOR leads the list with a score of 100 — an A grade based on consistently clean inspections. 13 of the top 20 carry an A grade; the rest sit in B-grade territory or lower. Average health score across this list: 96.6.
Showing top 20 of 30 seafood restaurants in Key West
THE MERMAID & THE ALLIGATOR
729 TRUMAN AVE, KEY WEST
100/100
PARADISE SEAFOOD COFFEE SHOP
6000 PENINSULAR AVE, KEY WEST
99.8/100
JIMMY'S OCEAN BLUE ABBEY ROAD
3675 S ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
99.5/100
THE LOBSTER SHACK KEY WEST
507 SOUTH ST STE A, KEY WEST
99.5/100
CONCH FLYER
3495 S ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
99.3/100
CONCH REPUBLIC SEAFOOD CO
631 GREENE ST, KEY WEST
98/100
PIRATE SEAFOOD
2300 N ROOSEVELT, KEY WEST
98/100
A&B LOBSTER HOUSE/BERLINS
700 FRONT STREET SUITE #2 & #3, KEY WEST
97.9/100
YELLOWFIN
5950 PENINSULAR AVE, KEY WEST
97.8/100
THE WHITE TARPON / BEL MARE
700 FRONT ST #104, KEY WEST
97.8/100
A&B LOBSTER HOUSE/ALONZO'S/BERLINS
700 FRONT ST. SUITE 106 & 107, KEY WEST
97.3/100
DUFFYS STEAK AND LOBSTER HOUSE
1007 SIMONTON ST, KEY WEST
96.5/100
LOUIE'S BACKYARD
700 WADDELL AVE, KEY WEST
96.3/100
ALONZO'S OYSTER BAR
700 FRONT ST SUITE #1, KEY WEST
94.8/100
DJ'S CLAM SHACK
629 DUVAL STREET, KEY WEST
94.4/100
EATON STREET SEAFOOD MARKET
801 EATON ST, KEY WEST
94.1/100
THIRSTY MERMAID
521 FLEMING STREET, KEY WEST
93.3/100
STONED CRAB RESTAURANT
3101 N ROOSEVELT BLVD, KEY WEST
93.1/100
SEVEN FISH
921 TRUMAN AVENUE, KEY WEST
93/100
KEY WEST CONCH FRITTERS
1 WHITEHEAD ST, KEY WEST
92/100
