Islamorada, Florida
Monroe County · 86 restaurants
Islamorada is a Monroe County community with 86 restaurants tracked by Florida DBPR inspectors. 34.9% earn an A grade with an average InspectFL Health Score of 89.4 out of 100. That's slightly below the Florida statewide average for A grades — worth checking individual scores before you eat. 4 restaurants currently hold an F grade (4.7%) — worth knowing before you sit down. Browse current scores, violation histories, and full inspection details for each restaurant below.
Data on this page
InspectFL turns public DBPR inspection records into city-level score trends, grade breakdowns, and restaurant history so this page is useful for comparison, not just a list of names.
How to use this city page
Start with the citywide grade mix, then use filters to narrow by category, grade, or inspection dates before opening the full restaurant record.
What the citywide data means
Islamorada's grade mix looks fairly mixed, so this page is best used to narrow the list before checking each restaurant's full record.
Best supporting links
How to read a restaurant page, editorial standards, and corrections.
About Dining in Islamorada
Of Islamorada's 86 graded restaurants, 34.9% earned an A grade — below the statewide average, suggesting room for improvement in local food safety. Currently, 4.7% of restaurants hold a failing F grade, representing 4 establishments with significant health violations. The average InspectFL Health Score across Islamorada is 89.4 out of 100, based on 186 inspections on record.
What Inspectors Look For
Florida DBPR inspectors evaluate restaurants on food temperature control, employee hygiene, pest activity, and equipment cleanliness. Violations are categorized as critical (immediate health risk), major (significant concern), or minor (procedural issue). Learn more about how grades work.
Explore More
- Monroe County restaurants — see all cities in this county
- City rankings — compare this city with others across Florida
- Editorial standards — understand what is official vs. InspectFL analysis
- InspectFL Blog — analysis, trends, and deep dives on Florida restaurant inspections
Highest Rated in Islamorada
Lowest Rated in Islamorada
Restaurants
Page 2 of 4MERCADO MORADA
84001 OVERSEAS HWY
LOBSTER SHACK
86700 OVERSEAS HWY LOT E
MIDWAY CAFE & COFFEE BAR
80499 OVERSEAS HWY
NICKY’S GRILL
MM 84721 OVERSEAS HY
SPORTS PUB
84500 OVERSEAS HWY
TACOS JALISCO 2
81611 OLD HWY
CHEF MICHAEL'S
81671 OLD HIGHWAY
LORELEI OF ISLAMORADA
96 MADEIRA RD
TAKE TWO
80401 OLD HIGHWAY
THE ISLAMORADA FISHING CLUB
104 MADEIRA RD
ISLAMORADA FISH COMPANY LLC
81532 OVERSEAS HWY
BITTON BISTRO CAFE
82245 OVERSEAS HWY
ITALIAN FOOD COMPANY
82779 OVERSEAS HWY
MARATHON BAGEL CO LLC @ ISLAMORADA
86701 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY STE 5 & 6
THREE WATERS RESORT MARINA - MAIN KITCHEN/TIKI BAR/KOKOMOS
84001 OVERSEAS HWY
CASA MORADA
136 MADEIRA ROAD
CHESAPEAKE BEACH RESORT
83409 OVERSEAS HWY
GREEN TURTLE INN
81219 OVERSEAS HWY
EL JARDIN
81001 OVERSEAS HWY UNIT 3
THE BEACH CAFE
81610 OVERSEAS HWY
SIDECAR
80241 OVERSEAS HWY
KEYS CHOCOLATES & ICE CREAM
81933 OVERSEAS HWY STE C
KINDLER
84001 OVERSEAS HWY
OCEAN HOUSE
82779 OLD HWY
SWORDFISH GRILL AT BUDNMARYS
79851 OVERSEAS HWY
Important context for city pages
City pages are comparison tools built from public Florida DBPR inspection data. They help surface local patterns quickly, but they are not official government rankings and they should not replace reading the individual restaurant page before making a decision.
